Introduction: Both formats put bulk solids into a bag, but one builds the bag during the filling cycle while the other arrives finished and waiting.
A line engineer comparing these two formats usually starts with the same practical question: where does the bag actually come from? The answer decides how the line is laid out, what has to be stored before a run, and what an operator touches between product changes. Tubular FFS film and pre-made open-mouth bags both handle granular and powdered solids well; the real difference sits in whether bag making belongs to the machine or to a separate converting step. Understanding that split makes the rest of the comparison much easier to follow.
On a tubular FFS line, the bag does not exist until the machine makes it. Film comes off a roll, passes over a forming collar, and wraps into a vertical tube. A longitudinal sealer closes the overlap, a bottom sealer creates the floor of the bag, the fill spout drops bulk solids into the open tube, and a top sealer closes the bag before a knife cuts it free. Every bag is created, filled, and sealed in one continuous sequence, so the roll is the only bag material the line ever handles. That sequence moves several decisions off the line and into the film itself. The flat width of the roll sets the tube circumference, which is why tubular FFS film from a polyethylene film manufacturer is specified across a 400–760 mm width range and paired with a gusset of up to 100 mm when a bag needs side volume. Thickness in the 0.07–0.24 mm band shapes how the film behaves on the collar and at the seal bar. Roll diameter, up to 1500 mm, sets how much film sits on one core. Three-layer coextrusion builds the film as a single structure with skin and core working together. Bag length, meanwhile, is set on the machine, not ordered from a converter.
Pre-made open-mouth bags arrive finished. A converter has already formed the tube, sealed the bottom, cut the bag to length, printed it, and packed it into cartons or onto wickets. On the line, an operator or a robot lifts a bag from a magazine, grippers or air jets open the mouth, the fill spout charges the product, and a closing station sews, glues, or heat-seals the top. Bag shape, mouth geometry, gusset depth, print layout, and closure style were all settled long before the bag reached the plant. That fixed shape is not a weakness; it is the reason the format stays in service. A pre-made bag holds its own form. It stacks flat in a carton, gets counted, and is issued to the line in the quantity a run needs. When a bulk solid demands a specific mouth opening, a particular gusset profile, or a printed panel that must line up on a pallet, the converting step handles it once and every bag matches. The trade-off is that the line inherits those dimensions, so a size or style change begins at the bag supply rather than at the machine.
The four differences below follow from that single split: whether the bag is built on the line or delivered ready to open. None of them is a ranking. They describe how each format behaves, so an engineer can predict where attention will land during a shift.
Read together, those four points explain why the formats are rarely swapped on the same machine without engineering work. One treats the roll as raw material and the machine as the bag maker. The other treats the bag as a finished component and the machine as a handler and closer.
The cleanest way to compare tubular FFS film and pre-made open-mouth bags is to ask where bag making sits in the process. Online forming keeps creation inside the cycle, so film width, thickness, gusset, and roll diameter carry the geometry, and bag length stays a machine setting. Pre-made bags keep creation at the converter, so the line receives a fixed shape that stacks flat and opens predictably. Neither format wins on principle; the line layout, the bag style a bulk solid needs, and where a plant prefers to hold inventory decide which one fits. Readers comparing formats can start by mapping bag creation onto their own process flow.
A: The roll holds the entire bag supply as flat film, so a plant stores one roll format instead of several carton sizes of finished bags. Bag length is set on the machine within the limits of the film width, which means a single roll can serve more than one finished bag length. Storage space then follows the number of rolls on hand rather than the number of bag sizes a product range happens to need.
A: FFS film is formed into a tube on the machine, sealed at the bottom, filled through the open tube, and sealed at the top before cutting. An open-mouth bag arrives already formed and bottom-sealed, so the line only has to pick it up, open the mouth, fill it, and close the top. The dividing line is whether bag creation happens during the filling cycle or before it.
A: Generally no. An FFS machine is built around a forming collar, a vertical tube, and seal bars that work on continuous film, so it has no magazine or bag-opening station to feed a finished bag. Pre-made bags run on separate bagging equipment with a bag pick-up and mouth-opening mechanism. A plant moving between the two formats is changing line architecture, not just the bag supply.
Flexible Packaging Association | FPA
PMMI, The Association for Packaging and Processing Technologies
Plastics Industry Association | Advocacy & Sustainability